1. The Weight of Stoicism: Historical Roots of “Real Men Don’t Cry”
From ancient warrior codes to Victorian stoicism, history has lionised men who bear pain in silence. Emperors, knights, and explorers were celebrated for their unflinching resolve in the face of danger. Over time, these ideals morphed into the “stiff upper lip”: a cultural script prescribing that men must remain calm, controlled, and unemotional. Any display of feeling - particularly tears - risked being labelled unmanly, effeminate, or weak.
While modern life no longer demands literal battlefield heroics, the legacy of stoicism remains. Boys learn early on that expressing sadness or fear will invite ridicule or shame. Parents might say, “Big boys don’t cry,” or peers might mock a classmate who lets tears fall. By adulthood, many men have internalised the message that tears are taboo - a dangerous falsehood that disconnects them from their own emotional needs.
2. Biology and Empathy: Debunking the “Gendered Tears” Myth
It’s sometimes argued that women are simply more emotional than men - that they cry more often because their hormones make them fragile. Yet scientific research tells a more nuanced story:
Tear Production Differences: Studies show that women produce more baseline tears due to dynamics of tear film maintenance, but emotional tears are linked more to socialisation than biology.1
Emotional Processing: Neuroimaging reveals that both men and women engage similar brain regions when experiencing sadness or empathy; gender differences in crying often stem from learned behaviour and cultural expectations.2
In essence, the capacity to cry is human, not gendered. Men are just as likely to feel intense grief, frustration, or tenderness - but they learn early on to suppress the most visible sign of those feelings.
3. Costs of Suppression: The Toll on Mental Health
Silencing tears doesn’t eliminate pain - it stores it away, often with serious consequences:
Increased Anxiety and Depression: Men who routinely bottle up emotions are at higher risk for mood disorders. Without healthy outlets, stress compounds, leading to chronic anxiety or depressive episodes.
Substance Abuse and Aggression: Emotional numbness can fuel self-medication through alcohol or drugs. Alternatively, pent-up feelings may explode as anger or aggression, damaging relationships.
Barrier to Help-Seeking: The stereotype that “real men don’t talk about feelings” discourages men from seeking therapy or support groups. Statistics show that while men complete suicide at higher rates, they seek mental-health care far less often than women.
Encouraging men to cry - and to speak about why - can be a form of emotional release, reducing the risk of these negative outcomes.
4. Toward a Healthier Masculinity: Why We Should Embrace Male Tears
Reimagining masculinity to include vulnerability brings clear benefits:
Deeper Relationships
When men allow themselves to cry, they open doors to intimacy and empathy. Partners, friends, and family members feel invited to share their own feelings, strengthening bonds.Emotional Intelligence
Recognising and naming feelings is the first step toward effective communication and conflict resolution. Crying can be a healthy signal that prompts reflection and growth.Role Modelling for the Next Generation
Boys who see male role models - from fathers to teachers - expressing sadness learn that vulnerability is human, not shameful. This breaks the cycle of emotional repression.
5. Practical Steps: Supporting Male Vulnerability
How can individuals and communities help men feel safe enough to cry?
Normalise the Moment: If a man cries, avoid gaslighting (“You’re overreacting”) or mocking. Instead, offer a tissue, a calm presence, and a gentle question like “Do you want to talk about it?”
Language Matters: Replace phrases like “man up” or “toughen up” with “it’s okay to feel this way.” Even small shifts in wording signal permission to express.
Create Safe Spaces: Men’s support groups, coaching circles, or even book clubs can offer structured environments where sharing is encouraged. Professional therapy should be de-stigmatised and made more accessible.
Lead by Example: Fathers, coaches, and leaders should model emotional openness - sharing their own struggles and tears when appropriate. Visibility matters.
6. Conclusion: The Power of Shared Tears
Tears are a bridge between hearts. When men cry, they remind us of our shared vulnerability and humanity. Breaking free from the outdated script that labels male emotion as weakness is not merely a matter of individual well-being; it’s a societal imperative. By embracing male vulnerability, we pave the way for healthier relationships, stronger communities, and a world where everyone - regardless of gender - feels safe to let their tears fall.
Embracing male tears doesn’t diminish strength; it redefines it. True courage lies not in hiding pain, but in acknowledging and sharing it.
Footnotes
Vingerhoets, A. J. J. M., & Cornelius, R. R. (2001). Adult crying: A model and review of the literature. Review of General Psychology. ↩
Frewen, P. A., et al. (2008). Neural correlates of tearful sadness: An fMRI study. NeuroImage. ↩
© 2025 Marlena Pakula. All Rights Reserved.